In an ordinary suburban home in 1970s England, a series of terrifying events would lead to one of the best-documented cases of paranormal activity ever recorded.
Known as the Enfield poltergeist, the extraordinary events centred around the Hodgson family, residents of the London suburb of Ponders End in Enfield.
The household consisted of Peggy Hodgson — a single mother and her 4 children Margaret, age 13, Janet, age 11, Johnny, age 10 and Billy, age 7.
The strange events that enfolded in Enfield would arguably become the most thoroughly studied case of poltergeist activity in history, but it continues to divide opinion as to its veracity.
Sceptics point out obvious elements of fakery amongst the children, chiefly Janet, but advocates point out the number of inexplicable phenomena experienced by neutral observers, including policeman and reporters.
The first sign of unusual activity came in August 1977 when the girl’s mother phoned police complaining of knocking sounds and moving furniture in Janet’s bedroom.
Neighbours and passers-by had already witnessed some of the activity and Peggy had become so frightened by what was happening that she ordered the children out of the house.
When the police arrived they too heard knocking sounds and one constable even saw a chair slide across the floor. The officers were suspicious, but despite a thorough investigation they were unable to find the source of the activity.
Reporters, paranormal investigators and priests were subsequently called in and the case quickly become a national and international cause célèbre.
During the next 18 months of intense scrutiny by investigators — especially Maurice Grosse from the Society for Psychical Research, over 2000 unexplained events were recorded, including incidents of levitating children, demonic possession, loud noises and moving furniture.
Many of the inexplicable events were captured in a series of famous photographs. However, incidents of fakery from the children were also noted by observers, some of whom still insisted real paranormal events also occurred.
Were the Hodgson family really tormented by a poltergeist?
Evidence for
Photographs
Investigators set up 2 automatic cameras in the girls bedroom designed to take images at half second intervals in the events of any unusual activity.
During the time they were active, they captured instances of pillows flying off the bed, curtains twisting around and most sensationally of all, 11-year-old Janet flying off the bed and seemingly levitating in mid-air.
Whilst the possibility that the girls were faking the incidents is obvious, the photographs have a verisimilitude about them that is hard to overcome.
The terror on the participants faces in many of them is obvious, and clearly those present were convinced what was happening was genuine.
Number of observers
The number of disinterested parties involved who experienced unusual activity is striking. Reporters for several national newspapers, the BBC, police officers, priests and neighbours all reported experiencing inexplicable phenomena.
Michael Hellicar, a journalist for the Daily Mail in London experienced many of the events first hand — “…I experienced cold draughts, graffiti, water puddles appearing from nowhere, bad smells, and chairs and tables moving of their own accord”.
…I experienced cold draughts, graffiti, water puddles appearing from nowhere, bad smells, and chairs and tables moving of their own accord
Daily Mirror reports Graham Morris and Douglas Bence were convinced enough by what they had observed to persuade their paper to report its first paranormal story since 1929.
Amongst the most convincing independent witnesses were the police officers who were called to the Hodgson’s home soon after the poltergeist first made its presence felt in August 1977.
WPC Carolyn Heeps recalls the unusual phenomena — “I saw a chair slide off to the right about four feet before it came to rest. I checked to see if it could have slid along the floor by itself. I even placed a marble on the floor to see whether it would roll in the same direction as the chair. It didn’t.”
Bill Wilkins
Months into the investigation, Janet started to speak in a strange, guttural voice quite unlike that of an 11-year-old girl.
The voice was husky and often foul-mouthed and identified itself as Bill, a man who had died in the house some years prior. This was an event nobody in the Hodgson family claimed to have any knowledge of.
Months later, a man by the name of Terry Wilkins came forward. Terry’s father had lived in the Hodgson home years before and, according to Terry, had died of a hemorrhage in his favorite chair on the first floor.
Extraordinary, his name was Bill. Was this a lucky guess on the part of Janet? Or was she really possessed by a restless spirit?
Evidence against
Fakery
The children, specifically Janet, were caught out on several occasions faking supernatural phenomena.
Anita Gregory and John Beloff, alongside Maurice Grosse investigators with the SPR, spent a few days with the family and came to the conclusion that the children had faked the poltergeist activity.
On one occasion, the pair caught Janet red handed trying to bend a spoon, perhaps influenced by the coverage of Israeli psychic Uri Gellar in the media.
Janet even admitted that she had fabricated some of the occurrences. She featured on the ITV news in 1980 admitting the fakery — “Oh yeah, once or twice, just to see if Mr Grosse and Mr Playfair would catch us. And they always did.”
Maurice Grosse
Several skeptics have pointed out that Maurice Grosse, the central figure in the investigation of the Enfield Poltergeist, was troubled at the time of the events.
Grosse had lost his own daughter, also called Janet, in a motorcycle accident just a year before the Enfield hauntings begun. Did he want to believe the activity was real as a way of making some sense of his loss?
The girls had also recently suffered upheavals, having just lived through their parent’s divorce. An experience that is traumatic for all children, did it precipitate the strange events that baffled the world?
Were the Hodgson family really tormented by a poltergeist?